Dynamic Input/Output Automata: a Formal and Compositional Model for Dynamic Systems

We present dynamic I/O automata (DIOA), a compositional model of dynamic systems, based on I/O automata. In our model, automata can be created and destroyed dynamically, as computation proceeds. In addition, an automaton can dynamically change its signature, that is, the set of actions in which it can participate. This allows us to model mobility, by enforcing the constraint that only automata at the same location may synchronize on common actions. Our model features operators for parallel composition, action hiding, and action renaming. It also features a notion of automaton creation, and a notion of trace inclusion from one dynamic system to another, which can be used to prove that one system implements the other. Our model is hierarchical: a dynamically changing system of interacting automata is itself modeled as a single automaton that is "one level higher." This can be repeated, so that an automaton that represents such a dynamic system can itself be created and destroyed. We can thus model the addition and removal of entire subsystems with a single action. We establish fundamental compositionality results for DIOA: if one component is replaced by another whose traces are a subset of the former, then the set of traces of the system as a whole can only be reduced, and not increased, i.e., no new behaviors are added. That is, parallel composition, action hiding, and action renaming, are all monotonic with respect to trace inclusion. We also show that, under certain technical conditions, automaton creation is monotonic with respect to trace inclusion: if a system creates automaton Ai instead of (previously) creating automaton A'i, and the traces of Ai are a subset of the traces of A'i,then the set of traces of the overall system is possibly reduced, but not increased. Our trace inclusion results imply that trace equivalence is a congruence relation with respect to parallel composition, action hiding, and action renaming. Our trace inclusion results enable a design and refinement methodology based solely on the notion of externally visible behavior, and which is therefore independent of specific methods of establishing trace inclusion. It permits the refinement of components and subsystems in isolation from the entire system, and provides more flexibility in refinement than a methodology which is, for example, based on the monotonicity of forward simulation with respect to parallel composition. In the latter, every automaton must be refined using forward simulation, whereas in our framework different automata can be refined using different methods. The DIOA model was defined to support the analysis of mobile agent systems, in a joint project with researchers at Nippon Telegraph and Telephone. It can also be used for other forms of dynamic systems, such as systems described by means of object-oriented programs, and systems containing services with changing access permissions

Special issue on DISC 2010

This special issue of Distributed Computing is based on papers that originally appeared as extended abstracts in the Proceedings of the 24th International Symposium on Distributed Computing (DISC2010), held in Cambridge, Massachusetts on August 13–15, 2010. The papers for the Special Issue were chosen by the Program Committee from the 32 regular papers presented at the Symposium, based on their quality and representation of the spectrum of topics encompassed by the Symposium. In addition to being reviewed, in preliminary form, by the Program Committee, the full papers submitted for the Special Issue were refereed according to the standard practices of Distributed Computing (due to time constrains, some papers could not appear in this volume). We thank the Members of the Editorial Board for their work in editing this issue, and the referees and the authors of these papers for their respective contributions

Perspectives on the CAP Theorem

Almost twelve years ago, in 2000, Eric Brewer introduced the idea that there is a fundamental trade-off between consistency, availability, and partition tolerance. This trade-off, which has become known as the CAP Theorem, has been widely discussed ever since. In this paper, we review the CAP Theorem and situate it within the broader context of distributed computing theory. We then discuss the practical implications of the CAP Theorem, and explore some general techniques for coping with the inherent trade-offs that it implies

RADON: Repairable Atomic Data Object in Networks

Erasure codes offer an efficient way to decrease storage and communication costs while implementing atomic memory service in asynchronous distributed storage systems. In this paper, we provide erasure-code-based algorithms having the additional ability to perform background repair of crashed nodes. A repair operation of a node in the crashed state is triggered externally, and is carried out by the concerned node via message exchanges with other active nodes in the system. Upon completion of repair, the node re-enters active state, and resumes participation in ongoing and future read, write, and repair operations. To guarantee liveness and atomicity simultaneously, existing works assume either the presence of nodes with stable storage, or presence of nodes that never crash during the execution. We demand neither of these; instead we consider a natural, yet practical network stability condition N1 that only restricts the number of nodes in the crashed/repair state during broadcast of any message. We present an erasure-code based algorithm RADON_{C} that is always live, and guarantees atomicity as long as condition N1 holds. In situations when the number of concurrent writes is limited, RADON_{C} has significantly improved storage and communication cost over a replication-based algorithm RADON_{R}, which also works under N1. We further show how a slightly stronger network stability condition N2 can be used to construct algorithms that never violate atomicity. The guarantee of atomicity comes at the expense of having an additional phase during the read and write operations

Relativization of the theory of computational complexity.

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Mathematics, 1972.Vita.Bibliography: leaves 123-124.Ph.D

A proof of the Kahn principle for input/output automata

AbstractWe use input/output automata to define a simple and general model of networks of concurrently executing, nondeterministic processes that communicate through unidirectional, named ports. A notion of the input/output relation computed by a process is defined, and determinate processes are defined to be processes whose input/output relations are single-valued. We show that determinate processes compute continuous functions, and that networks of determinate processes obey Kahn's fixed-point principle. Although these results are already known, our contribution lies in the fact that the input/output automata model yields extremely simple proofs of them (the simplest we have seen), in spite of its generality

Admission control and routing : theory and practice

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 1995.Includes bibliographical references (leaves 183-190).by Rainer Gawlick.Ph.D

A verification framework for hybrid systems

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2007.Includes bibliographical references (p. 193-205) and index.Combining; discrete state transitions with differential equations, Hybrid system models provide an expressive formalism for describing software systems that interact with a physical environment. Automatically checking properties, such as invariance and stability, is extremely hard for general hybrid models, and therefore current research focuses on models with restricted expressive power. In this thesis we take a complementary approach by developing proof techniques that are not necessarily automatic, but are applicable to a general class of hybrid systems. Three components of this thesis, namely, (i) semantics for ordinary and probabilistic hybrid models, (ii) methods for proving invariance, stability, and abstraction, and (iii) software tools supporting (i) and (ii), are integrated within a common mathematical framework. (i) For specifying nonprobabilistic hybrid models, we present Structured Hybrid I/O Automata (SHIOAs) which adds control theory-inspired structures, namely state models, to the existing Hybrid I/O Automata, thereby facilitating description of continuous behavior. We introduce a generalization of SHIOAs which allows both nondeterministic and stochastic transitions and develop the trace-based semantics for this framework. (ii) We present two techniques for establishing lower-bounds on average dwell time (ADT) for SHIOA models. This provides a sufficient condition of establishing stability for SHIOAs with stable state models. A new simulation-based technique which is sound for proving ADT-equivalence of SHIOAs is proposed. We develop notions of approximate implementation and corresponding proof techniques for Probabilistic I/O Automata. Specifically, a PIOA A is an E-approximate implementation of B, if every trace distribution of A is c-close to some trace distribution of B-closeness being measured by a metric on the space of trace distributions.(cont.) We present a new class of real-valued simulation functions for proving c-approximate implementations, and demonstrate their utility in quantitatively reasoning about probabilistic safety and termination. (iii) We introduce a specification language for SHIOAs and a theorem prover interface for this language. The latter consists of a translator to typed high order logic and a set of PVS-strategies that partially automate the above verification techniques within the PVS theorem prover.by Sayan Mitra.Ph.D

Lower bounds in distributed computing

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2008.Includes bibliographical references (p. 167-170).Distributed computing is the study of achieving cooperative behavior between independent computing processes with possibly conflicting goals. Distributed computing is ubiquitous in the Internet, wireless networks, multi-core and multi-processor computers, teams of mobile robots, etc. In this thesis, we study two fundamental distributed computing problems, clock synchronization and mutual exclusion. Our contributions are as follows. 1. We introduce the gradient clock synchronization (GCS) problem. As in traditional clock synchronization, a group of nodes in a bounded delay communication network try to synchronize their logical clocks, by reading their hardware clocks and exchanging messages. We say the distance between two nodes is the uncertainty in message delay between the nodes, and we say the clock skew between the nodes is their difference in logical clock values. GCS studies clock skew as a function of distance. We show that surprisingly, every clock synchronization algorithm exhibits some execution in which two nodes at distance one apart have Q( lo~gD clock skew, where D is the maximum distance between any pair of nodes. 2. We present an energy efficient and fault tolerant clock synchronization algorithm suitable for wireless networks. The algorithm synchronizes nodes to each other, as well as to real time. It satisfies a relaxed gradient property. That is, it guarantees that, using certain reasonable operating parameters, nearby nodes are well synchronized most of the time. 3. We study the mutual exclusion (mutex) problem, in which a set of processes in a shared memory system compete for exclusive access to a shared resource. We prove a tight Q(n log n) lower bound on the time for n processes to each access the resource once. .(cont.) Our novel proof technique is based on separately lower bounding the amount of information needed for solving mutex, and upper bounding the amount of information any mutex algorithm can acquire in each step. We hope that our results offer fresh ways of looking at classical problems, and point to interesting new open problemsby Rui Fan.Ph.D